Home Education Injury rehabilitation
Injury rehabilitation
Knee pain and the loading it needs
The most common belief about knees is that they have a fixed mileage. It is also the one most clearly contradicted by the research.
In short
- Running is not associated with higher rates of knee osteoarthritis; recreational runners have lower rates than sedentary people.
- Exercise is a first-line treatment for knee osteoarthritis, and it reduces pain and improves function.
- Most non-traumatic knee pain in active people is a loading problem around the kneecap or the tendons.
- Loading a painful knee progressively, including deep positions over time, is usually the treatment rather than the risk.
The wearing out model, and why it fails
Cartilage is not a brake pad. It is living tissue that responds to load, and studies of recreational runners consistently find equal or lower rates of knee osteoarthritis compared with sedentary people. Competitive and elite athletes in some sports do show higher rates, which is a different exposure from a few runs a week.
The same applies to squatting, stairs and kneeling. Loads within tolerance maintain joints. Loads that jump well beyond tolerance irritate them, which is a dose argument and not a case against the movement.
What usually hurts, and why
- Pain around or under the kneecap, often with squatting, stairs and sitting. Commonly follows an increase in training volume or a long period of relatively little.
- Pain at the tendon below the kneecap, typical in jumping sports, with a characteristic pattern of warming up and then hurting afterward.
- Pain on the outside of the knee in runners, usually related to volume and running mechanics rather than a structure that needs releasing.
- Osteoarthritic knee pain, usually with stiffness after rest, better with movement, worse with sudden increases.
What these share is a relationship with recent load. The single most informative question in a knee history is what changed in the eight weeks before it started.
Osteoarthritis and exercise
Exercise is recommended as a core treatment for knee osteoarthritis in every major guideline, and it reduces pain and improves function with effect sizes comparable to medication. Arthroscopic surgery for degenerative knee disease, including for degenerative meniscal tears, has repeatedly failed to outperform exercise or placebo procedures in trials.
The practical version: a knee with arthritic change still needs loading, it still gets stronger, and strength is one of the few things that reliably changes how it feels.
How to load a painful knee
- Start with the range and the load you tolerate today, which may be partial-range or isometric.
- Load the quadriceps properly. Insufficient quadriceps strength is the most common finding and the most consistently useful thing to fix.
- Add range gradually, including deeper positions, over weeks rather than in one jump.
- Use the 24-hour rule: discomfort during loading that settles by the next day is acceptable.
- Keep going for three months. Knee tendon and strength changes are slow and reliably frustrating.
What is not settled
Which specific exercises are best for patellofemoral and tendon-related knee pain is not settled, and most comparisons find similar outcomes. Why some knees develop osteoarthritis and others do not remains largely unexplained, and the relationship between cartilage findings and symptoms is weak. What is clear is that the use-wears-it-out model is not supported.
Keep reading
Related in this hub
Injury rehabilitation
When rest alone has not worked
Three months off and it still hurts when you go back. That is information, not bad luck.
Injury rehabilitation
Hip and groin pain in active people
An area with several plausible sources, a lot of overlap, and a much better response to loading than its reputation suggests.
Injury rehabilitation
How long does rehabilitation actually take?
The honest answer has ranges in it, and the ranges are longer than most people hope and shorter than they fear.
ScoliosisScoliosis and pain
Had enough of waiting for it to settle?
An assessment identifies what is driving it and what the first four weeks should contain. Beirut or online.